Chapter notes
One entry for each chapter. The entries use these headings:
- Time: a rough estimate in class sessions of about 90 minutes, including a lab. It depends on how much of the chapter’s code is run in class.
- Data: the data sets the chapter loads with
nwwebuse, and any small networks it types in. - Builds on: the earlier chapters it draws on. Part I and Chapters 4 to 6 are common ground for all chapters after them.
- Commands: the commands of the package that the chapter teaches.
- Where students get stuck: taken from the chapter’s box of common mistakes and from its hints.
- Exercises: the number of exercises at each level, with their numbers. Exercises are numbered in the order in which they appear in the chapter, as in the book.
- Part I. Foundations
- Part II. Describing and positioning networks
- Chapter 4. Working with networks in Stata
- Chapter 5. Seeing networks
- Chapter 6. Describing networks
- Chapter 7. Paths, distance, and reachability
- Chapter 8. Centrality, brokerage, and structural holes
- Chapter 9. Cohesion, subgroups, and communities
- Chapter 10. Positions, roles, and structural equivalence
- Chapter 11. Ego networks
- Chapter 12. Two-mode networks
- Chapter 13. Valued, signed, and multiplex networks
- Chapter 14. Networks over time
- Part III. Simulating networks
- Part IV. Statistical inference for networks
- Chapter 18. Random networks and null models
- Chapter 19. Permutation inference and comparing networks
- Chapter 20. QAP regression
- Chapter 21. Exponential random graph models
- Chapter 22. Advanced exponential random graph models
- Chapter 23. Latent space and block models
- Chapter 24. Influence and contagion
- Chapter 25. Stochastic actor-oriented models
- Chapter 26. Advanced stochastic actor-oriented models
- Chapter 27. Relational event models
- Chapter 28. The Dynamic Network Actor Model
- Part V. Doing network research
- Appendices
Part I. Foundations
Chapter 1. Why networks?
- Time: 1 session. There is no code.
- Data: none; the examples are described in words.
- Builds on: nothing.
- Commands: none.
- Where students get stuck:
- Equating exposure with adoption. The network supplies only the exposure, and the bridges that speed an infection can slow a behavior that needs reinforcement.
- Inferring influence from a cross-sectional similarity, or from a group mean of an outcome, which the reflection problem leaves ambiguous.
- Calling any data set with several units a network, although it has nothing on who is connected to whom.
- Telling attributes from relations: the hints ask whether a quantity can be written down for one unit without mentioning any other unit.
- Keeping a score apart from the idea it stands for: what betweenness counts is not yet brokerage (Ex. 11).
- Exercises: 12. Basic 6 (1–6); applied 4 (7–10); open 2 (11, 12).
Chapter 2. What is a network?
- Time: 1 session.
- Data:
lazega; a four-person networkmini, typed in. - Builds on: 1.
- Commands:
nwset,nwsummarize,nwdegree,nwplot,nwsym,nwsubset,nwtoedge. - Where students get stuck:
- Converting one type of network into another without saying so. Symmetrizing the advice network turns 892 arcs into 700 edges and erases who asked whom.
- Comparing the directed and the undirected density of the same network as if they measured the same thing; they divide by different numbers of possible ties.
- Treating a subset as the network: the eight lawyers that can be checked by hand have a density of 0.161 and two look isolated; in the whole firm the density is 0.179 and nobody is isolated.
- Reading the adjacency matrix the wrong way round. Rows are senders and columns receivers here; a source with the opposite convention flips every arrow without an error message.
- Counting mutual pairs: a mutual pair holds two arcs but becomes one edge (Ex. 7).
- Exercises: 8. Basic 4 (1–4); applied 3 (5–7); open 1 (8).
Chapter 3. From a research question to a network and a method
- Time: 1 session.
- Data:
lazega. - Builds on: 1, 2.
- Commands:
nwdyads,nwsymwithmode(max)(the OR rule) andmode(min)(the AND rule). - Where students get stuck:
- Comparing networks collected with different ceilings on the number of names. Measures built from degree are not comparable, although both files have a column called degree.
- Reporting a whole-network analysis without its response rate. The edge list looks complete whoever is missing.
- Asking an ego-network design to answer a whole-network question. Closeness, betweenness and communities cannot be recovered from ego data.
- The reconciliation rules: the AND rule keeps the mutual pairs, the OR rule the mutual and the one-sided pairs (Ex. 2, 3, 8). For the lawyers’ friendship reports they give 74 and 501 edges.
- Exercises: 10. Basic 3 (1–3); applied 6 (4–9); open 1 (10).
Part II. Describing and positioning networks
Chapter 4. Working with networks in Stata
- Time: 1–2 sessions, most of it in the lab.
- Data:
lazega,florentine,glasgow; a toy network declared from a matrix, a small survey export, and an example edge list read withnwimport. - Builds on: 2, 3.
- Commands:
nwset(edge list andmat()),nwimport,nwfromedge,nwsummarize,nwclear,nwsave,nwuse,nwload,nwname,nwgenerate,nwreplace,nwsubset,nwkeepnodes,nwduplicate,nwsymmetrize,nwdegree. - Where students get stuck:
- Treating a nomination as a tie. The
undirectedoption applies the union rule silently (five ties from eight nominations in the chapter’s example). - Losing isolates. An edge list holds only people who appear in a tie; the others drop out of n and inflate density and every average. Give each a row with an empty receiver, or declare the network from a matrix.
- Trusting the type that
nwimportinfers. Check theDirected:andValued:lines ofnwsummarizeagainst the design. - Expecting
clearto remove networks. It removes the data in memory, not the declared networks; usenwclear. - Typing a matrix for
nwset, mat(): row i, column j holds the arc from i to j, and rows are separated by a backslash (Ex. 1).
- Treating a nomination as a tie. The
- Exercises: 8. Basic 3 (1–3); applied 4 (4–7); open 1 (8).
Chapter 5. Seeing networks
- Time: 1–2 sessions, most of it in the lab.
- Data:
florentine,lazega,usair(drawn on the base mapusmap),chesapeake. - Builds on: 4.
- Commands:
nwplot(layouts,color(),symbol(),size(),edgesize(),generate()andnodexy(),basemap(),interactive),nwplotmatrix,nwpathto highlight a path,nwsubset,nwgenerate. - Where students get stuck:
- Reading node position as a finding. The same network can look centered on one actor in one layout and undifferentiated in another.
- Comparing pictures of one network at different times without fixed coordinates;
generate()andnodexy()keep the positions. - Mapping a rank as a size. The lawyers’
seniorityis 1 for the most senior, so as a size it draws the picture upside down. - Moving nodes on a page with real coordinates. Recolor and resize, but leave the nodes.
- Reproducing an interactive page: the saved do-file needs the same data and the same node order as when the page was written (Ex. 8).
- Exercises: 11. Basic 3 (1–3); applied 7 (4–10); open 1 (11).
Chapter 6. Describing networks
- Time: 1–2 sessions.
- Data:
lazega,gang,glasgow. - Builds on: 2, 4, 5.
- Commands:
nwsummarize,nwdyads,nwtriads,nwmixing,nwassortativity,nwdegree. - Where students get stuck:
- Comparing density across networks of different size. The lawyers’ 0.179 and the Glasgow girls’ 0.046 are not a comparison of cohesion.
- Reading the E-I index against zero. The chance value is about +0.41 for the gang’s birthplace groups and -0.05 for the lawyers’ offices.
- Reading the smallest permutation p-value as a precise value. With 100 permutations it is 0.02, so the honest report is p ≤ 0.02.
- Mixing relations in one comparison: transitivity is 0.33, 0.36 or 0.19 depending on the relation of the firm.
- Reciprocity of pairs and of arcs count different things (Ex. 2).
- Exercises: 12. Basic 4 (1–4); applied 6 (5–10); open 2 (11, 12).
Chapter 7. Paths, distance, and reachability
- Time: 1 session.
- Data:
lazega,florentine,glasgow;usairin Ex. 8. - Builds on: 4, 6.
- Commands:
nwgeodesic(withunconnected()),nwpath,nwreach,nwneighbor,nwrandom,nwtriads. - Where students get stuck:
- Treating distance as defined for disconnected pairs without a stated rule. The diameter and radius of 16 for the Florentine marriage network are the penalty, not path lengths, and the average of 4.175 is 2.49 among the connected pairs.
- Treating distance as symmetric in a directed network. From
n59ton23the advice distance is four; back it is three. - Comparing averages taken over different sets of pairs: for a network with unreachable pairs,
nwgeodesicreports the share of connected pairs and the average over those pairs (Ex. 3). - Reading a short average distance as a small world. That needs clustering and a random baseline as well (Ex. 8).
- Exercises: 10. Basic 4 (1–4); applied 4 (5–8); open 2 (9, 10).
Chapter 8. Centrality, brokerage, and structural holes
- Time: 2 sessions.
- Data:
florentine,lazega. - Builds on: 6, 7.
- Commands:
nwdegree,nwcloseness,nwbetween,nwevcent,nwkatz,nwburt,nwbrokerage,nwbridges,nwsimmelian,nwsym. - Where students get stuck:
- Ignoring direction without saying so. On the symmetrized network, closeness, betweenness, eigenvector and Katz centrality answer a question about the structure, not about who asks whom. Directed closeness correlates .96 with out-degree. Use in-degree for “who is sought”.
- Leaving unreachable pairs to a hidden rule. Changing the rule changes the closeness of every node not fully connected to the rest (Ex. 4).
- Assuming
nwkatzis the walk-counting Katz measure of textbooks. By default it sums over shortest-path distances; the optionwalksgives the textbook version. - Reading a high score as power or influence. What a position is worth needs outcome data.
- Reading brokerage role counts without the grouping variable in mind. A binary grouping cannot produce a liaison, and counts grow with the number of two-paths, so compare shares as well.
- Exercises: 12. Basic 4 (1, 2, 3, 8); applied 6 (4–7, 9, 10); open 2 (11, 12).
Chapter 9. Cohesion, subgroups, and communities
- Time: 2 sessions.
- Data:
lazega,gang,macaque;florentinein Ex. 2. - Builds on: 6, 7.
- Commands:
nwsym,nwcomponents,nwclique,nwkplex,nwnclique,nwkcore,nwkcomponents,nwcohesion,nwcommunity(Louvain, Leiden, Infomap, label propagation),nwmodularity,nwplot. - Where students get stuck:
- Forgetting that n-clique paths can leave the group, so two members may be connected only through outsiders.
- Reporting a community result without the algorithm, its settings and the partition sizes. Louvain and label propagation return four communities against one on the advice network, and a bare count hides singletons.
- Comparing the modularity of a detected partition with that of a known one as if both had been chosen the same way. The detected partition was selected for its high modularity.
- Not stating the version of a directed relation. Reciprocated ties (
mode(min)) give a much smaller network than ties in either direction (mode(max)). - Taking a k-core for a group that is hard to pull apart. A k-core is a minimum-degree condition; only k-components and the cohesion hierarchy test connectivity (Ex. 1).
- Exercises: 8. Basic 2 (1, 2); applied 4 (3–6); open 2 (7, 8).
Chapter 10. Positions, roles, and structural equivalence
- Time: 2 sessions.
- Data: a small office typed in;
lazega;florentine. - Builds on: 8, 9.
- Commands:
nwsimindex,nwregular,nwconcor,nwcollapse,nwhierarchy,nwdendrogram,nwcoreperiphery,nwplotmatrix,nwtoedge;nwdissimilarfor directed profiles;nwsbm(Chapter 23) when the number of blocks should come from the data. - Where students get stuck:
- Running
nwconcorornwhierarchyon two-mode data, which stops with error 6088. Project first, or cluster the profiles of one mode. - Forgetting that CONCOR rejects isolates, which can appear after symmetrizing or subsetting.
- Trusting the default linkage. Single linkage put 68 lawyers in one cluster and three in singletons.
- Reading within-block density from
nwcollapse, whose image network has no diagonal. - Reading pooled Jaccard similarity as a directed comparison; use
nwdissimilarwhen direction matters. - Expecting exact regular equivalence to find roles in dense data: one class for all 71 lawyers in the advice network, one class per lawyer in the friendship network.
- Structural equivalence by hand: a tie between the two actors compared does not count (Ex. 1, 3).
- Running
- Exercises: 10. Basic 3 (1–3); applied 6 (4–9); open 1 (10).
Chapter 11. Ego networks
- Time: 1 session.
- Data:
lazega,glasgow; a small personal-network survey typed in. - Builds on: 4, 7, 8.
- Commands:
nwego,nwegoplot,nwaltergen(proportion(),diversity(),hop(),net()),nwdegree;collapsefor survey data. - Where students get stuck:
- Letting a missing ego measure shrink a sample. Four of the 50 Glasgow girls name no friend, so their exposure is missing and a regression drops them; density is missing for every ego with fewer than two alters.
- Entering size, density, effective size and constraint in one model, where the coefficients are unstable.
- Reading composition as preference without a baseline of what the setting makes available.
- Forgetting which network a command uses.
nwaltergenwithoutnet()takes the most recently created network. - Applying
diversity()to a continuous variable such as tenure or age.
- Exercises: 10. Basic 3 (1–3); applied 5 (4–8); open 2 (9, 10).
Chapter 12. Two-mode networks
- Time: 1–2 sessions.
- Data:
davis. - Builds on: 6, 8, 9.
- Commands:
nw2toedge,nwdegreeandnwclusteringfor two-mode networks,nw2project(stat(count),stat(binary),stat(jaccard)),nwcommunity,nwplot. - Where students get stuck:
- Applying one-mode measures to raw two-mode data. Some commands stop with error 6088; others return a number for the bipartite graph read as one-mode, without normalization by mode. The command reference (Appendix C) lists how every command treats a two-mode network.
- Reading a dense binary projection as informative: 91% of all pairs of the Southern women are tied in it.
- Letting large groups dominate a projection. A group of m members produces m(m−1)/2 projected ties.
- Density and degree in two modes: they divide by the size of the other mode (Ex. 2, 3).
- Exercises: 9. Basic 4 (1–4); applied 4 (5–8); open 1 (9).
Chapter 13. Valued, signed, and multiplex networks
- Time: 2 sessions.
- Data:
lazega,gang(valued),chesapeake,gahuku,senate114,senate93. - Builds on: 6, 8.
- Commands:
nwtabulate,nwrecode,nwcorrelate,nwbalance,nwdegree(strength),nwbetween(weighted andbinary),nwgen. - Where students get stuck:
- Dichotomizing without reporting it. The recode in the chapter changes 133 of 315 ties. Commands differ in
whether they use the values;
binaryswitches them off, and each command prints which it used. - Taking the “changes made” line of
nwrecodefor a count of ties. It counts matrix cells, two per undirected tie. - Treating a negative tie as a missing one, or a missing tie as neutral.
- Quoting a balance percentage without a baseline. With 39% positive ties, random signs already give 49% balanced triads; say whether the strong or the weak version is meant.
- Reading inferred signs as likes and dislikes. The Senate signs compare co-sponsorship with what chance would give (Ex. 11).
- Dichotomizing without reporting it. The recode in the chapter changes 133 of 315 ties. Commands differ in
whether they use the values;
- Exercises: 14. Basic 5 (1, 2, 5, 6, 7); applied 8 (3, 4, 8–13); open 1 (14).
Chapter 14. Networks over time
- Time: 1 session; the section on adoption over the waves (Section 14.6) adds about half a session.
- Data:
glasgow(the three waves of the friendship network and the smoking variables); a small timestamped edge list typed in. - Builds on: 3, 5, 6.
- Commands:
nwturnover(withformation),nwgen,nwplotwithgenerate()andnodexy(),nwmovie,nwdiffuse curve,nwdiffuse exposureandnwdiffuse threshold(toa(),generate(),count(),lag()),nwset ..., time(),nwattime. - Where students get stuck:
- Comparing waves collected under different name-generator ceilings or boundary rules, which produces turnover that reflects measurement.
- Comparing turnover across studies with different intervals between waves.
- Using a movie in place of turnover statistics. An animation shows where change happened, not how much.
- Reading turnover as the speed of the process: ties formed and dissolved within an interval are never seen.
- Jaccard index and persistence have different denominators: all ties present in either wave, or the ties of the first wave (Ex. 2).
- Counting exposure in the same wave as the adoption. With
lag(1)a girl is exposed only by friends who adopted in an earlier wave, so exposure is missing for the first wave. Adoption is permanent in the data: a girl who stops smoking is still an adopter. - Using one network for all waves of the adoption data. The friendship network of the first wave stands for all three here; that is acceptable for friendships named in one survey and wrong when ties form or end between waves.
- Exercises: 8. Basic 3 (1–3); applied 4 (4–7); open 1 (8).
Part III. Simulating networks
Chapter 15. Random and structured network generators
- Time: 1–2 sessions.
- Data:
lazegafor comparison; generated networks. - Builds on: 6, 7.
- Commands:
nwrandom,nwring,nwlattice,nwsmall,nwpref,nwgen,nwgeodesic,nwdegree,nwsummarize,nwplot. - Where students get stuck:
- Reading a single draw as the model’s typical outcome. Five draws of the same random graph gave transitivities from 0.175 to 0.181; ten graphs with 16 nodes ranged from 0 to 0.364.
- Forgetting
set seed, so that nothing downstream is reproducible. - Overlooking defaults:
nwlatticeandnwsmallproduce directed networks unlessundirectedis specified. - Predicting chance levels: in a random graph every possible tie is present with the same probability, so the expected transitivity is about the density (Ex. 2, 3).
- Exercises: 9. Basic 4 (1–4); applied 4 (5–8); open 1 (9).
Chapter 16. Generating networks from attributes and tie probabilities
- Time: 1–2 sessions.
- Data:
lazega. - Builds on: 6, 9, 15.
- Commands:
nwexpand,nwgen,nwdyadprob,nwhomophily,nwmixing,nwtoedge,nwfromedge;logitandpredicton the edge list. - Where students get stuck:
- Getting the direction wrong.
nwdyadprobproduces a directed network by default, even from a symmetric probability network. - Passing values that are not probabilities. Values outside 0 to 1 are treated as log-odds, without a warning.
- Reading a homophily coefficient as a probability. It is a log-odds ratio:
homophily(3)multiplies the odds of a within-group tie by about 20. - Judging an estimated generator by what it was fitted to. Only features outside the model, such as reciprocity and transitivity, test it.
- Expected E-I values: they follow from the group sizes, as one minus twice the share of within-group pairs (Ex. 3).
- Getting the direction wrong.
- Exercises: 10. Basic 3 (1–3); applied 6 (4–9); open 1 (10).
Chapter 17. Network structure and diffusion
- Time: 2 sessions. Students write and modify small Stata programs.
- Data: generated networks only (a small world of 200 nodes, the same ring with 1 or 5 percent of its ties rewired, and random graphs with the same mean degree).
- Builds on: 7, 11 (
nwcontext), 15. Chapter 24 takes up adoption in observed data, andnwdiffuse(Chapter 14, Section 14.6, and Chapter 24) measures exposure and thresholds there. - Commands:
nwsmall,nwrandom,nwcontext; the programsdiffuse,seedgroupandexperiment, written in the chapter; frames to collect results. - Where students get stuck:
- Starting complex contagion with a single adopter. With a threshold of two, nobody ever has two adopting neighbors (Ex. 4).
- Letting the starting group change with the network. Fix its size and the rule that picks it, as
seedgroupdoes. - Comparing networks with different numbers of ties. Hold size and mean degree fixed.
- Reporting one run, or only a mean. Report the share of runs that succeed and the spread over many networks and starting groups.
- Using the wrong direction of ties.
nwcontextcounts the neighbors a node sends ties to unlessmode()says otherwise; usemode(incoming)for a process that travels from sender to receiver.
- Exercises: 6. Basic 2 (1, 2); applied 3 (3–5); open 1 (6).
Part IV. Statistical inference for networks
Chapter 18. Random networks and null models
- Time: 1 session.
- Data:
lazega;glasgowin Ex. 4. - Builds on: 6, 15.
- Commands:
nwcugwithcondition(density),condition(census)andcondition(degrees), andplot;nwrandom. - Where students get stuck:
- Calling a statistic high or low without a reference distribution. A transitivity of 0.33 means little until it is set against the 0.179 that chance gives at that density.
- Reading a significant result as evidence for a mechanism. Rejecting the density null leaves closure, office sorting and a few very busy lawyers all in play.
- Comparing tests with different conditioning without noticing. The calls differ by one word.
- Choosing the p-value column: a claim that a statistic is larger than chance concerns one tail (Ex. 1).
- Exercises: 6. Basic 3 (1–3); applied 2 (4, 5); open 1 (6).
Chapter 19. Permutation inference and comparing networks
- Time: 1 session.
- Data:
lazega. - Builds on: 6, 18.
- Commands:
nwpermute,nwcorrelate,nwmixingwithpermutations(). - Where students get stuck:
- Running an ordinary correlation or regression on dyadic data. The rows share nodes and are not independent.
- Confusing permutation with random-graph generation. The CUG test draws new networks; permutation relabels the observed one.
- Using too few permutations. The two-sided p-value cannot be smaller than 2/(R+1); a value at that floor means more permutations are needed if a finer value matters (Ex. 2).
- Exercises: 6. Basic 3 (1–3); applied 2 (4, 5); open 1 (6).
Chapter 20. QAP regression
- Time: 1 session.
- Data:
lazega,glasgow. - Builds on: 18, 19.
- Commands:
nwqap(qapspp,plot,mode(),type(regress),predict()),nwgen,nwtoedge. - Where students get stuck:
- Reporting QAP p-values as if they came from an ordinary regression. They come from refitting the model on permuted networks.
- Forgetting that a coefficient controls only for what is in the model. The friendship coefficient is 2.47 in one model and 2.20 in another.
- Using too few permutations for the precision claimed: 500 permutations cannot tell 0.003 from 0.004.
- Not reporting the routine and the number of permutations when predictors are correlated.
- Turning a logit coefficient into a probability: add the coefficients that apply to the constant, then apply 1/(1+e−x) (Ex. 1).
- Exercises: 9. Basic 2 (1, 2); applied 6 (3–8); open 1 (9).
Chapter 21. Exponential random graph models
- Time: 2–3 sessions.
- Data:
lazega. - Builds on: 6, 7, 18, 19, 20.
- Commands:
nwergm(edges,mutual,nodematch(),nodeofactor(),nodeifactor(),gwesp(),edgecov()),estat mcmcdiag,estat gof,estimates store,lrtest,predict. - Where students get stuck:
- Reporting a coefficient because MCMLE converged. The message records only that the algorithm stopped; read
estat mcmcdiagafter every fit, since effective sample sizes can be a few dozen among thousands of draws. - Treating good fit on the model’s own statistics as proof. That agreement is guaranteed; the final advice model still misses the spread of the out-degrees and the number of pairs at distance 2.
- Reading a coefficient: it compares the conditional log-odds of one tie for two pairs that differ only in that term, with every other tie held fixed (Ex. 1).
- Reporting a coefficient because MCMLE converged. The message records only that the algorithm stopped; read
- Exercises: 10. Basic 2 (1, 2); applied 7 (3–9); open 1 (10).
Chapter 22. Advanced exponential random graph models
- Time: 2 sessions.
- Data:
lazega,mesa. - Builds on: 18, 21.
- Commands:
nwergm simulate,nwergmon an undirected network and with missing dyads,nwtomata; a small programsimsummarywritten in the chapter;nwergmwithestimate(bayes)(burnin(),iterations(),thin(),priormean(),priorvar()),estat posterior,estat mcmcdiag. - Where students get stuck:
- Treating a coefficient as if it controlled only its own statistic. Setting the
mutualcoefficient to zero also lowered the density; setting the gwesp coefficient to zero cut it to a third. Adjustedgesand report the density with every comparison. - Using raw triad counts (
triangle,ctriple) on a clustered network. On Faux Mesa High estimation stops; usegwesp. - Reading the posterior of the Bayesian fit without looking at the chains. Read the Gelman-Rubin statistic and
the effective sample sizes in
estat mcmcdiag; a single chain can still drift a little over 10,000 iterations. Some options of the main workflow (constraints, operators, networks with missing dyads) are not available withestimate(bayes). - Losing the node attributes.
nwergm simulatekeeps the data in memory when the draws are on the same nodes; with any other number of nodes it replaces the data, so run it betweenpreserveandrestore. - Coding a missing dyad as a non-tie. Leave it missing;
nwergmthen leaves it out of the likelihood, which assumes the dyads are missing at random.
- Treating a coefficient as if it controlled only its own statistic. Setting the
- Exercises: 7. Basic 2 (1, 2); applied 5 (3–7). Ex. 7 belongs to the section on the Bayesian ERGM (Section 22.7).
Chapter 23. Latent space and block models
- Time: 1–2 sessions. The latent space fit takes from several seconds to about a minute; the block model is quick.
- Data:
lazega. - Builds on: 9, 10 (the blockmodel image), 21; 22 for reading MCMC chains.
- Commands:
nwsbm(blocks(),maxblocks(),generate(),seed()),nwlsm(dim(),nsample(),burnin(),interval(),chains()),nwlsmplot,estat mcmcdiag,estat gof;tabulateandencodeto set the blocks against office, practice and rank. - Common idea: the chapter opens with what the two models share, so teach it first. Each actor has a hidden attribute (a block, or a position); ties are independent once it is known; the amount of hidden structure is chosen; the attribute is known only up to relabeling; no model term stands for reciprocity or closure.
- Where students get stuck:
- Treating the number of blocks as a finding. The ICL picks four blocks for the advice network, but three blocks are close (−2158 against −2162). Report the table of ICL values.
- Reading a block as a social group. Members of one block need not know each other: the 20 associates of block 4 are alike in whom they ask and who asks them.
- Reading the axes of the latent space. Positions are identified up to rotation, reflection and translation; interpret distances and neighborhoods, not directions, and do not compare the coordinates of two fits (Ex. 2).
- Skipping the chain checks of
nwlsm. Readestat mcmcdiag(effective sample sizes, Geweke z, Gelman-Rubin) before the picture, and lengthenburnin()andnsample()when it asks for it. - Reporting the fit of a model of independent ties as if dependence did not matter. Both models assume independence
given the hidden structure; the distance panel of
estat goffits here, but shared partners have not been checked.
- Exercises: 5. Basic 2 (1, 2); applied 2 (3, 4); open 1 (5).
Chapter 24. Influence and contagion
- Time: 2 sessions. The section on the autologistic model is the longest and can be set as reading.
- Data:
glasgow(the friendship network and smoking in three waves; drinking in the second wave);lazegain Ex. 4 and 5. - Builds on: 11 (the exposure regression), 14 (Section 14.6 on adoption over the waves), 17, 21 (MCMC diagnostics); 25 for the model that separates influence from selection.
- Commands:
nwdiffuse long(toa(),lag(),clear) withlogit;nwdiffuse threshold;nwspmatrixwith Stata’sspregressanddvarlag();nwalaam(effects(density contagion sender receiver),mple,ego(),method()),estat mcmcdiag,estat gof,nwalaam simulate. - Where students get stuck:
- Reading exposure or contagion as influence. Friends who influence each other, girls who choose friends who already smoke and a shared school give the same coefficient; say “associated with”.
- Forgetting who is at risk. The girls who smoked in the first wave have no rows in the hazard data (Ex. 1).
- Reading the spatial lag as the effect of one friend. With a row-normalized matrix it multiplies the average of the friends’ outcomes, and a girl without friends has a lag of 0 (Ex. 2).
- Trusting the standard errors of a plain logistic regression on rows of girls who are tied to each other.
- Treating the two codings of a binary outcome in the autologistic model as mirror images. Contagion counts ties between actors who have the outcome, so the litigation coding of Ex. 5 does not converge when the corporate coding of Ex. 4 does.
- Comparing contagion coefficients across networks with different numbers of ties (Ex. 4).
- Exercises: 6. Basic 2 (1, 2); applied 2 (3, 4); open 2 (5, 6).
Chapter 25. Stochastic actor-oriented models
- Time: 2 sessions.
- Data:
glasgow. - Builds on: 14, 21 (the first sections, on effect statistics and change statistics); 20 for the contrast with a model of one wave.
- Commands:
nwsaom(wave1(),wave2(),waves(),outdegree,reciprocity,transtrip,nodematch(),behavior(),behsim,avalt),nwsaom describe,nwsaom refit,estat gof. - Where students get stuck:
- Reading the convergence t-ratios as significance tests, or the table’s z as a convergence check.
- Expecting any behavior to identify a co-evolution model. Alcohol use (five levels) supports one in the Glasgow data; smoking (three levels, rarely changing) gives very imprecise behavior estimates.
- Fitting an SAOM to data that is not a panel.
nwsaomneeds two or more waves on the same actors, with joiners and leavers declared throughpresent(). - Comparing coefficients of
avsimandavalt, which measure influence on different scales; compare signs and p-values (Ex. 5).
- Exercises: 9. Basic 3 (1, 4, 7); applied 4 (2, 3, 5, 6); open 2 (8, 9).
Chapter 26. Advanced stochastic actor-oriented models
- Time: 2 sessions.
- Data:
glasgow;baerveldt19(19 Dutch schools, two waves). - Builds on: 25.
- Commands:
estat score,estat timetest,estat importance,estat simulate,estat mems,nwsaom simulate,nwsaomwithml,nwsaom bayes,nwsaom multinet(described),nwstack,nwsaomwithgroups(),nwsaom meta. - Where students get stuck:
- Freeing every effect that the score test flags in one step. Each test is conditional on the effects in the model at that moment.
- Reading a short Bayesian run to the last digit. The effective sample size says how many independent draws the chain is worth; the ends of a credible interval need hundreds.
- Interpreting the cross-network coefficient of
nwsaom multinetwhen one network is nearly a subset of the other. It then records the overlap. - Reporting the standard errors of a joint model without a heterogeneity check. They are too small when the groups do not share their effects.
- Exercises: 5. Basic 1 (1); applied 2 (2, 3); open 2 (4, 5).
Chapter 27. Relational event models
- Time: 1–2 sessions.
- Data:
manufacturing(the first two weeks,keep if t < 14); a ten-event toy log typed in. - Builds on: 14 and the first sections of 21; 25 for the comparisons the chapter draws.
- Commands:
nwset ..., eventtime(),nwrem(nodsnd,nidrec,frpsndsnd,rsndsnd,covevent()),nwload ..., xvars,nwexpand. - Where students get stuck:
- Looking for an intercept. The likelihood compares pairs at the same instant, so none can be estimated.
- Quoting a single
nodsndornidreccoefficient as stable; both shift with the other effects in the model. - Building a
covevent()network from the event rows. It needs one row per actor, fromnwloadwithxvars. - The risk set: at each event every ordered pair of actors is at risk, 129 × 128 for the email log (Ex. 2).
- Exercises: 8. Basic 3 (1–3); applied 3 (4–6); open 2 (7, 8).
Chapter 28. The Dynamic Network Actor Model
- Time: 1–2 sessions.
- Data:
manufacturing; the toy log of Chapter 27 in Ex. 2. - Builds on: 27.
- Commands:
nwset ..., eventtime() directed,nwdynam(submodel(rate), the choice sub-model,intercept,inertia,recip,indeg,outdeg,same()),nwload ..., xvars. - Where students get stuck:
- Reading
indegandoutdegthe same way in both sub-models. In the rate sub-model they describe the acting actor, in the choice sub-model the candidate receiver. - Taking an order-only fit for one that uses waiting times. Without
interceptthe rate sub-model is order-only, and the choice sub-model never has an intercept. - Declaring the event network without
directed.nwdynamthen stops; onlychoice_coordinationneeds an undirected network.
- Reading
- Exercises: 8. Basic 3 (1–3); applied 3 (4–6); open 2 (7, 8).
Part V. Doing network research
Chapter 29. A complete network analysis
- Time: 2 sessions.
- Data:
lazega;gangin Ex. 8. - Builds on: 6, 18, 20, 21; 9 and 22 for Ex. 7.
- Commands: no new commands; the chapter combines
nwtoedge,nwdegree,nwqap,nwergm(withnodemix(),nodeicov()andnodeocov()),lincom,estat,nwdropandestimates table. - Where students get stuck:
- Reading a receiver effect of status as deference. It shows only that partners are sought more.
- Counting the same finding three times. The density table, the QAP model and the ERGM use the same 892 arcs.
- Stopping at sender and receiver effects. They add up by construction;
nodemix()shows which pairs of groups carry the effect (here partners’ choices, not associates’). - Reading the cell names of
nodemix(): the sender’s level comes first, sonodemix_status_1_2is an associate asking a partner. - Reading a status effect as an effect of the title when partnership and seniority rank overlap.
- Choosing the sensitivity runs after seeing the results. State them with the expectations.
- Exercises: 9. Basic 4 (1–4); applied 3 (5–7); open 2 (8, 9).
Chapter 30. Reproducible and responsible network research
- Time: 1 session.
- Data:
lazega;glasgowin Ex. 5. - Builds on: 3, 5, 18, 29.
- Commands: stored results of
nwcugandnwqap(return list,ereturn list); in Ex. 5,postfileto collect results. - Where students get stuck:
- Treating the removal of names as anonymization. Structural re-identifiability has no analogue in ordinary data sets and must be assessed on its own terms.
- Expecting rerun plotting code to reproduce a figure. Unless the coordinates were saved, it will not.
- Citing a moving development version of the software instead of a specific, tagged one.
- Reading tail p-values: with the plus-one correction a tail p-value is (count + 1)/(R + 1) (Ex. 3).
- Exercises: 7. Basic 3 (1–3); applied 2 (4, 5); open 2 (6, 7).
Appendices
The appendices have no exercises. For teaching, the most useful are Appendix B (When things go wrong, on reading error codes) for the first labs, Appendix C (Command reference, with R and Python equivalents and the network types each command supports) for students who come from other software, Appendix D (Datasets used in this book) for planning, and Appendix A (Performance and network size) before students analyze large networks of their own. Appendix E is a mathematical reference and Appendix F collects the notation and a glossary. Programming with networks in Mata is not in the book; it is on the website, on the page Programming with networks in Mata.